Water & Environment · Nevada
Judge rules Nevada unconstitutionally took Coyote Springs water rights, and a jury will now decide damages
A district judge found the state's groundwater management amounted to a taking from the Coyote Springs developers, who seek $600 million plus interest. Lawyers disagree sharply on what the ruling means for Nevada water law.
Listen to this brief · 4 min
Read aloud by an AI voice from the text below. Download MP3
What happened
District Judge Mark Denton ruled against the state of Nevada on Wednesday in the long-running Coyote Springs water rights case, the Las Vegas Review-Journal reported. The case centered on state engineer determinations that plans to build a new city northeast of Las Vegas could not proceed. The ruling was one of Denton's final acts before retiring from the bench.
Denton found that the state's approach to managing groundwater in the area, which left the development plans useless, was an unconstitutional taking of private property, according to the Review-Journal. The newspaper described the decision as precedent-setting.
What taxpayers could owe
Damages go to a jury
A jury will decide damages in the next phase of the trial. The developer is seeking $600 million, plus interest and attorneys' fees. Laura FitzSimmons, one of the state's attorneys, told the Review-Journal that math works out to well over $1 billion.
"This decision is unfathomable," FitzSimmons told the Review-Journal. She said no court anywhere in the country had found a water permit to be a property right requiring compensation.
Who owns the land
The land straddles Clark and Lincoln counties and is owned by California developers Albert and Thomas Seeno. Coyote Springs was once planned to be twice the size of Summerlin, with as many as 160,000 homes, golf courses and hotel-casinos. The takings case was first filed in 2020.
Why lawyers disagree on the impact
Warnings of a crisis
Debbie Leonard, a Northern Nevada water attorney not involved in the case, told the Review-Journal the ruling "throws everything I've known and understood about Western water law into total chaos." She said the state engineer is now unlikely to grant new permits or extensions of time, which let developers hold water rights while they develop water resources. Leonard, who helped represent Las Vegas in the Badlands Golf Course case that ended in a $286 million city settlement, said that earlier ruling opened the door for Coyote Springs.
UNLV law professor Tom Romero wrote that the decision puts the state's ability to grant and administer water rights into flux. He noted the Nevada Supreme Court in 2024 upheld merging several connected basins into one superbasin, and said it is unclear whether officials should keep managing the region that way.
A win for property rights
Mark Hutchison, who represented the Seenos and was Nevada's Republican lieutenant governor from 2015 to 2019, said his clients ran out of legal remedies and are owed something in return. Damien M. Schiff of the Pacific Legal Foundation called the ruling a rare property rights win but said he does not expect it to be a "radical bellwether," because he sees the facts as narrow. More water coverage is on our water page.
A solar plan for the land
Hutchison said his clients have no plans to revive the city. "The answer is it's just solar," he told the Review-Journal, adding it is currently an option agreement. State energy regulators gave conditional approval in mid-October to an 8,177-acre, 1,200-megawatt solar project proposed by Reno-based Estuary Power, pending approvals from the state, Lincoln County and the Federal Aviation Administration.
NV Energy entered a power-purchase agreement for 600 megawatts from the first half of the project, which a utility spokeswoman said is pending state regulator approval. The Lincoln County Commission unanimously approved the development in early October, according to meeting minutes. Patrick Donnelly of the Center for Biological Diversity said the land is intact habitat for the Mojave desert tortoise, which is listed as threatened.
What to watch next
- A new judge will be assigned to oversee the damages phase, and it is not yet certain who that will be or how long it will take.
- The state's legal team has not decided whether to seek immediate relief from the Nevada Supreme Court or appeal after the second phase ends.
- NV Energy's 600-megawatt power-purchase agreement for the solar project is pending approval from state regulators.
- The solar project still needs additional state permits and Federal Aviation Administration approval for its second half.


