November 19, 2026Las Vegas 60°F · Rain Showers LikelyNewsletterSend a tip

Local reporting on the decisions that change daily life in the valley

Water & Environment · Nevada

Judge finds Nevada unconstitutionally took Coyote Springs water rights, sending damages question to a jury

A Clark County judge ruled the state engineer's actions amounted to an unconstitutional taking of water rights for the unbuilt Coyote Springs city. A jury will now weigh the developers' $600 million damages request.

Listen to this brief · 4 min

Read aloud by an AI voice from the text below. Download MP3

Rocky desert hills rise behind a scrub-covered gravel plain under a gray, cloudy sky
Illustrative photo: Rocky desert hills rise behind a scrub-covered gravel plain under a gray, cloudy sky. Photo by Ken Lund via Flickr, CC BY-SA 2.0.

What happened

A judge has ruled that Nevada unconstitutionally took water rights belonging to the developers of Coyote Springs, a planned Southern Nevada city that was never built, the Las Vegas Review-Journal reported. The case now moves to a second phase in which a jury will decide how much the state must pay the developers, known as Coyote Springs Investment, or CSI.

Mark Hutchison, the developers' attorney, told the Review-Journal his side is seeking $600 million in damages, plus interest and attorneys fees. That money would come from Nevada taxpayers if a jury awards it.

Inside the judge's ruling

Judge Mark Denton issued the ruling after a monthslong trial in Clark County that the Review-Journal described as precedent-setting. He wrote that "the actions (and inactions) and repeated course of conduct by the State Engineer caused the unconstitutional taking" CSI experienced.

How the water was limited

According to the Review-Journal, the state engineer ruled in 1997 that at least 18,000 acre-feet of water was available in the area. The office later combined scientifically connected basins into one, the Lower White River Flow System, and capped total pumping in that larger superbasin at 8,000 acre-feet. The area is home to the endangered Moapa dace, a small fish native to the Muddy River.

The Nevada Supreme Court upheld the state engineer's authority to combine basins in a 2024 decision. Denton, however, wrote that the order "was unprecedented and thus unforeseeable." He also wrote that the state encouraged the developers to keep spending money by approving time extensions that let them retain their water rights while pursuing their plans.

What the judge did not decide

The Review-Journal reported that Denton did not challenge the state engineer's ability to regulate water. Experts have described the case as a first-of-its-kind test of whether water rights count as property under a Nevada Constitution clause that bars the government from taking property without compensation.

Who testified and how each side responded

Over about three months, Denton heard testimony from several former Nevada state engineers, the Southern Nevada Water Authority, independent experts, and the developers and their employees, the Review-Journal reported. You can follow more coverage of regional supply issues on our water page.

The developers

Hutchison, who served as Nevada's Republican lieutenant governor from 2015 to 2019, said in a Wednesday interview that he was pleased with the ruling. He told the Review-Journal the case is "about accountability of the state engineer's office" and how it dealt with his client over many years.

The state

Nevada Attorney General's office spokesman John Sadler said Wednesday evening that the office was reviewing the ruling and had no further comment. The state engineer did not reply to an emailed inquiry from the Review-Journal.

Background on Coyote Springs

Lobbyist Harvey Whittemore first conceived Coyote Springs and bought the land in 1998 for $23 million, according to the Review-Journal. The Seeno family of California developers are now the sole owners.

The project was planned to be twice the size of Summerlin, with golf courses, hotel-casinos and other amenities. No homes stand there today, though the Review-Journal reported that watering a golf course has helped the developers hold onto their water rights for years. More on large-scale projects across the region is on our development page.

What to watch next

  • A jury will decide how much, if anything, the state owes CSI; Hutchison expects that phase to wrap up early next year.
  • Denton retires at the end of this year, and Judge-elect Adam Ganz will take over his department, but it is not yet clear which judge will see the case through.
  • The Nevada Attorney General's office said it was reviewing the ruling.
Section graphic: Water & Environment in the Las Vegas valley
More water & environment coverage: see all stories

Trending in Vegas

  1. Las Vegas Grand Prix Could Be Coldest F1 Race on RecordCommunity · Valley-wide
  2. Desert Pines High School Reopens Its LibrarySchools · Valley-wide
  3. Arts District BID Plan Ends After Owner, Resident PushbackDevelopment · Downtown Las Vegas
  4. Rosen Bill Would Limit ICE Operations at AirportsPublic Safety · Nevada
  5. Nevada Data Centers' Water Needs Hard to Pin Down, DRI SaysWater & Environment · Nevada

Get Las Vegas news in your inbox

The day's top local briefs every morning at 7:30, each linked to the newsroom that reported it.

Know more about this story?

If you were there, work on the project or have documents, tell us. Tips are read by a person and checked before anything is published.