Development · Nevada
Cortez Masto and Rosen split on Senate energy permitting bill over provisions Nevada tribes oppose
Sen. Jacky Rosen voted Monday to advance a bipartisan bill to speed permits for energy projects and data centers. Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto voted no over changes that Nevada tribal communities oppose.
Listen to this brief · 5 min
Read aloud by an AI voice from the text below. Download MP3

What happened
The U.S. Senate voted 73-25 on Monday to formally take up a bipartisan bill meant to speed permitting reviews for data centers and other infrastructure projects. The Associated Press reported the vote in a story published by The Nevada Independent. It was the first major Senate action since last week's midterm elections, which the AP said soundly repudiated President Donald Trump and congressional Republicans.
Nevada's two Democratic senators split on the vote. Sen. Jacky Rosen voted to move the bill forward. Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto voted against it, citing provisions that Nevada tribal communities oppose.
What the bill would do
According to the AP, the bill would shorten the timeline for starting large energy projects, both clean energy and fossil fuel. It would also require data centers to pay for the energy they use. Senators and the president have promoted it as a way to meet growing demand for electricity that now faces yearslong delays reaching the grid.
The AP reported that anger over artificial intelligence data centers and rising electricity prices helped bring in a wave of Democrats who pledged to clamp down on those facilities. The bill's four main sponsors are Sens. Shelley Moore Capito (R-WV), Mike Lee (R-UT), Martin Heinrich (D-NM) and Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI). On Saturday they released a detailed set of amendments meant to build support.
Offshore wind buyouts
Whitehouse said one provision would end the administration's practice of paying energy companies to walk away from offshore wind projects. The AP reported the administration has spent nearly $4 billion on those settlements. Trump told reporters Monday that he still opposes wind energy and that the bill "hasn't been fully negotiated."
Why Nevada's senators split
Rosen backs moving forward
Both senators initially voted to advance the legislation and praised its potential to lower costs and create jobs, though both also voiced reservations. In a statement last week, Rosen said further improvements should be made. She also wrote that "we cannot squander the opportunity to deliver results and lower costs for families."
Cortez Masto wants a tribal provision removed
Cortez Masto had promised to withhold support for final passage if the bill kept provisions changing the National Historic Preservation Act. That law requires the federal government to consult with tribal nations, and opponents say the bill would weaken it. On Monday she said she could not advance the bill without "a better guarantee" that the provisions would be dropped.
She told The Nevada Independent that the section was not in an earlier permitting bill and that tribes were left out when it was added. She said she told leadership she would support moving forward if they gave her an amendment to strike it, adding, "They're not giving me that amendment." As of Tuesday, she still had not seen the changes she wanted.
Cortez Masto said she and Sen. Adam Schiff (D-CA) are still pushing for the change and raised it at the Democratic caucus lunch on Tuesday. She said she believes the amendment might need only a 50-vote threshold, but Republicans will decide whether to allow it. Heinrich said he worked to include tribal leaders' feedback and that the amended version requires agencies to consult with tribes on projects affecting important cultural sites.
Supporters and opponents
In a Sunday social media post, Trump urged senators to back the bill and called it a "BIG WIN for U.S. ENERGY INDEPENDENCE and DOMINANCE." Industry groups also support it, including the American Clean Power Association and the American Petroleum Institute.
Environmental groups including the Sierra Club and the National Wildlife Federation oppose the measure. They cite its limits on judicial review and its changes to the National Environmental Policy Act and the Endangered Species Act. Bradley Campbell, president of the Conservation Law Foundation, said moving ahead in the waning days of the current Congress would be a "terrible mistake."
Lame-duck timing
The AP reported that the Democrats' midterm win could complicate the bill's passage. House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-NY), who is expected to become speaker in January, criticized the bill last week, and his office said it "falls short" in a number of areas. The Senate sponsors say they are optimistic it will pass both chambers, and Whitehouse said Trump's support should help it reach a House vote.
What to watch next
- Whether Senate Republicans allow a vote on the amendment Cortez Masto and Schiff are seeking to strike the National Historic Preservation Act provisions.
- Whether Cortez Masto supports final passage, which she has tied to removal of those provisions.
- Whether the bill moves to a House vote during the current lame-duck session.
- How the wind energy provisions are settled, after Trump said the bill has not been fully negotiated.


