AI & Tech · National
AI scribes are recording more doctor visits, and an NPR physician columnist explains how they work and where they fail
In an NPR column, a family physician explains how AI note-taking apps record and summarize exam room conversations, how the data is protected, and why errors and privacy concerns remain.
Listen to this brief · 5 min
Read aloud by an AI voice from the text below. Download MP3

What happened
NPR published a reader question answered by Dr. Mara Gordon, a family physician in Camden, N.J., who writes a monthly health column. The reader's doctor had begun recording office visits with an artificial intelligence scribe, and the reader wanted to know whether to worry about AI hearing private medical conversations.
Gordon wrote that AI scribes are now used widely, from gynecologist offices to emergency rooms, and that she uses one in her own primary care practice. She said the tool saves her time and lets her make eye contact with patients instead of watching a screen. She also wrote that she shares patients' privacy concerns and worries that health systems could pressure doctors to use the saved time to see more patients.
How an AI scribe works
Recording the visit
Gordon wrote that she first asks whether the patient is comfortable with the service, then starts recording with an app on her smartphone. The scribe uses automatic speech recognition, which separates the doctor's voice from the patient's and sometimes from family members in the room.
Turning a transcript into a note
After the visit, the recording is transcribed, and a large language model geared toward medicine turns it into a note in a standard format. According to NPR, the note covers what the patient said, physical exam findings and the doctor's decision-making. Products range from tools built into electronic medical records to free phone apps.

How patient data is protected
Where the recordings go
Gordon wrote that her patient conversations are not stored on her phone but are uploaded directly to a HIPAA-compliant cloud for transcription. HIPAA is the federal law meant to protect patient privacy. She wrote that scribe companies encrypt data, control access and are liable if data leaks, and that most systems delete the recording and note after a set period.
Recordings and research
According to the column, deleting recordings also protects doctors, since there is widespread concern in health care that transcripts could be used in malpractice lawsuits. Some researchers call the recordings "digital gold" that could help study note quality and doctor-patient communication. For now, NPR reported, routine visit recordings are not used for research unless a patient is enrolled in a study.
Errors and who is responsible
Mistakes the software makes
Gordon described a patient with metastatic cancer who did not accept his diagnosis; the AI note simply said he had been misdiagnosed. She wrote that she often catches errors such as the wrong gender or age, and that scribes are known to confuse "I do" with "I do not," which matters for a symptom like chest pain.
Dr. Eileen Kim, an assistant professor of internal medicine at the University of California San Diego, told NPR that rushed doctors may not fully review notes, and when other AI tools read them, "it just propagates errors throughout the chart."
Liability
Gordon wrote that she is ultimately responsible for each note and reads it carefully before signing. Most scribe software requires doctors to sign a user agreement stating they are liable for everything in the medical record.
Can patients say no?
Gordon wrote that patients who decline are not a problem; she simply takes notes on the computer as she did for years. Opting out of AI in medicine more broadly may prove tricky. Kim told NPR, "It's just everywhere."
Gordon wrote that software relying on machine learning is used for billing, clinical decision-making and communication with patients, as well as in risk calculators and early warning systems for conditions like sepsis. Kim said it is basically impossible to opt out entirely, "unless you're so healthy that no risk calculators ever come near you."
The column also notes that many AI scribes work only with English-speaking patients, and health equity advocates fear that could widen health disparities. More coverage is in our AI and technology section.
What to watch next
- Whether visit recordings that some researchers call "digital gold" are opened to research; NPR reported they currently are not unless a patient is enrolled in a study.
- Concerns from health equity advocates that English-only AI scribes could widen health disparities.
- Unresolved worry in health care that AI scribe transcripts could be used in malpractice lawsuits.
- Gordon's concern that health systems may push doctors to fill time saved by AI scribes with more patients.

