Nation · National
Justice Department tells appeals court its Alaska Senate certification lawsuit is moot as Peltola is projected to win
The Justice Department told the 9th Circuit its lawsuit aimed at potentially blocking certification of Alaska's Senate race is moot, ABC News reported, after the AP projected Democrat Mary Peltola will win.
Listen to this brief · 4 min
Read aloud by an AI voice from the text below. Download MP3
What happened
The U.S. Justice Department is abandoning a lawsuit that sought to potentially block certification of Alaska's U.S. Senate race, ABC News reported. In a filing with the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday evening, the department said the issue is now "moot." ABC News described the move as an apparent acknowledgment of Democratic Senator-elect Mary Peltola's current lead in the vote count.
The Associated Press projected on Tuesday that Peltola will win the seat, according to ABC News. The outlet reported that the result would be the ninth Senate pickup for Democrats in the next Congress. More coverage of races and results is on our elections page.
How the lawsuit began
Before the election, President Donald Trump directed the Justice Department to file a lawsuit in advance that would try to stop certification of the Alaska Senate race if Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan lost, ABC News reported. The administration pointed to possible confusion over candidate names as the basis for the case.
The name confusion claim
Two candidates in the race shared a similar name. Republicans alleged that candidate Dan J. Sullivan, described by ABC News as a retired teacher, ran a sham campaign meant to confuse voters and pull votes away from incumbent Sen. Dan S. Sullivan. The lawsuit centered on whether ballots cast for Dan J. Sullivan were intended for the senator.
The Nov. 1 dismissal
A federal judge in Alaska dismissed the lawsuit on Nov. 1, according to ABC News. The judge found there was "no workable plan" to investigate the claims as they related to the votes that had been submitted. The Justice Department then took the matter to the 9th Circuit.
What the Justice Department asked the appeals court
The Thursday filing came from Stanley Woodward, whom ABC News identified as the department's third-ranked official. Rather than continuing the fight, the department acknowledged the dispute is no longer worth further litigation. Even so, it asked the court to take a specific procedural step.
A request to vacate the dismissal
Woodward asked the appeals court to reject a motion to summarily affirm the lower court's judgment. Instead, he asked the 9th Circuit to vacate the district judge's order dismissing the case, "because the case has become moot," according to the filing quoted by ABC News.
A reluctant concession
In the filing, Woodward described the administration as having been dealt an unfair hand by being unable to contest ballots that may have been mistakenly cast for Dan J. Sullivan, ABC News reported. He wrote that the United States "reluctantly acknowledges that there no longer exists any means" of determining whether those votes were meant for the senator.
The political backdrop
The filing followed days of public pressure from the president. ABC News reported that Trump repeatedly called for the Alaska results to be decided in Sullivan's favor by combining his votes with those cast for Dan J. Sullivan. Trump also wanted to add votes for another Republican candidate whom he alleges Democrats unlawfully recruited as a spoiler.
ABC News described the lawsuit as controversial. For more national stories, visit our Nation section.
What to watch next
- How the 9th Circuit rules on the Justice Department's request to vacate the district court's dismissal order.
- Whether the appeals court grants or denies the pending motion to summarily affirm the lower court's judgment.
- Certification of Alaska's U.S. Senate race, which the lawsuit had sought to potentially block, with Peltola projected by the AP to win.

